Chapter 2 — Exploring Substances: Acidic, Basic, and Neutral
All activities, tables, in-text questions and the complete “Let Us Enhance Our Learning” exercise — solved with the chapter’s own figures.
Do you observe any change in the colour of the litmus pieces? Record your observations in Table 2.1.
| S.No. | Name of the sample | Colour of blue litmus after a drop | Colour of red litmus after a drop | Nature |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lemon juice | Turns red | No change (stays red) | Acidic |
| 2 | Soap solution | No change (stays blue) | Turns blue | Basic |
| 3 | Amla juice | Turns red | No change | Acidic |
| 4 | Tamarind water | Turns red | No change | Acidic |
| 5 | Vinegar | Turns red | No change | Acidic |
| 6 | Baking soda solution | No change | Turns blue | Basic |
| 7 | Lime water | No change | Turns blue | Basic |
| 8 | Tap water | No change | No change | Neutral |
| 9 | Washing powder solution | No change | Turns blue | Basic |
| 10 | Sugar solution | No change | No change | Neutral |
| 11 | Salt solution | No change | No change | Neutral |
| 12 | Any other — e.g. curd | Turns red | No change | Acidic |
Table 2.2 — Grouping of the samples
| Group A (turn blue litmus red) |
Group B (turn red litmus blue) |
Group C (no effect on either) |
|---|---|---|
| Lemon juice, Amla juice, Tamarind water, Vinegar, (Curd) | Soap solution, Baking soda solution, Lime water, Washing powder solution | Tap water, Sugar solution, Salt solution |
| → ACIDIC | → BASIC | → NEUTRAL |
What are these red and blue litmus paper strips made of? Why do they change colour when drops of some samples are put on them?
- Litmus is a natural substance obtained from lichens.
- It is available both as a solution and as paper strips (litmus paper), in two colours — blue and red.
- It changes colour because it shows different colours in acidic and basic solutions: it turns red in acids and blue in bases.
- Because of this property it is called an acid-base indicator.
Are all the substances in Group A edible? What is their taste? Find out and write the names of the most common acids present in — Lemon ____, Curd ____, Tamarind ____, Vinegar ____.
Not all Group A substances are edible, but the edible ones (lemon juice, amla juice, tamarind water, vinegar, curd) all taste sour. Hence, substances that taste sour tend to contain acids and are acidic in nature.
| Substance | Most common acid present |
|---|---|
| Orange | Citric acid |
| Amla | Ascorbic acid (Vitamin C) and Citric acid |
| Tamarind | Tartaric acid |
| Tomato | Citric acid and Oxalic acid |
| Lemon | Citric acid |
| Curd | Lactic acid |
| Vinegar | Acetic acid |
Rubbing the baking soda solution between the fingers — what do you observe?
- It feels soapy / slippery. Basic substances are generally slippery to touch.
- Bases generally taste bitter — but everything bitter is not basic. For example, bitter gourd (karela) tastes bitter yet is not basic in nature.
If litmus is not available, are there other natural substances that can serve as acid-base indicators? How is the red rose extract prepared? (Activity 2.3)
Yes. Many natural substances act as indicators — red rose petals, red hibiscus (gudhal), purple cabbage, beetroot, turmeric, Indian blackberry (jamun), etc.
Preparation of red rose extract — step by step
Add lemon juice to test tube A and soap solution to test tube B (each containing red rose extract). Record the colour changes in Table 2.3.
| S.No. | Name of the sample | Colour of the red rose extract after adding the sample | Nature of the substance |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lemon juice | Turns a shade of red | Acidic |
| 2 | Soap solution | Turns a shade of green | Basic |
| 3 | Amla juice | Red | Acidic |
| 4 | Tamarind water / Vinegar | Red | Acidic |
| 5 | Baking soda solution / Lime water / Washing powder solution | Green | Basic |
| 6 | Tap water / Sugar solution / Salt solution | No change | Neutral |
The three discussion questions
- Are the samples that turn the extract red the same as those that turned blue litmus red (Group A)? — Yes. Both tests identify the same acidic substances.
- Are the samples that turn the extract green the same as those that turned red litmus blue (Group B)? — Yes. Both identify the same basic substances.
- Are the samples that do not change the extract the same as those that did not change either litmus (Group C)? — Yes. These are the neutral substances.
Fascinating Facts: Can gardeners alter the colour of hydrangea flowers by adjusting the acidic or basic nature of the soil?
Yes. The hydrangea plant behaves like a living indicator:
- Acidic soil → blue-coloured flowers.
- Basic soil → pink or red flowers.
So a gardener can make the soil more acidic (to get blue flowers) or more basic — for example by adding lime, a base (to get pink/red flowers) — and thus change the colour of the flowers.
Prepare turmeric paper and test all the samples of Activity 2.1. Record in Table 2.4. Do all samples change the colour of the turmeric paper? Can turmeric paper be used as an indicator for acidic substances?
Preparation (step by step)
Table 2.4 — Completed
| S.No. | Name of the sample | Colour of the turmeric paper after a drop | Nature |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lemon juice | No change (stays yellow) | Acidic |
| 2 | Soap solution | Turns red | Basic |
| 3 | Amla juice | No change (yellow) | Acidic |
| 4 | Tamarind water, Vinegar | No change (yellow) | Acidic |
| 5 | Baking soda solution, Lime water, Washing powder solution | Turns red | Basic |
| 6 | Tap water, Sugar solution, Salt solution | No change (yellow) | Neutral |
Answers to the questions
- Do all samples change the colour? — No. Only the basic samples turn the yellow turmeric paper red.
- Samples that do not change the colour: all of Group A (acidic) and all of Group C (neutral).
- Can turmeric paper be used as an indicator for acidic substances? — No. Turmeric paper can be used to test basic substances, but it cannot differentiate between acidic and neutral substances, because both leave it unchanged.
Ashwin applied turmeric paste on white paper, dried it, and wrote his Guru Purnima wishes on it using one of the solutions of Table 2.4. Which solution can be used to write the message?
He must use a basic solution — such as soap solution (or baking soda solution / lime water / washing powder solution).
Reason
- The dried paper is coated with yellow turmeric.
- A base turns turmeric red. So the letters written with the soap solution appear in red on the yellow background — a clearly visible message.
- An acidic or a neutral solution would leave the paper yellow, so nothing would be seen.
Are there substances whose odour changes on adding acidic or basic substances? What do you observe with the onion strips?
Yes. Substances whose odour changes in an acidic or a basic medium are called olfactory indicators (from olfaction = sense of smell).
Observations of the activity
Lemon juice + water + a drop of blue litmus solution, then lime water added drop by drop, then one more drop of lemon juice. Can you predict why there is a change in colour?
Neutralisation
When the solution of an acid is mixed with the solution of a base in sufficient quantity, the resulting solution is neither acidic nor basic. Such a reaction is called a neutralisation reaction. In it, salt and water are formed with the evolution (release) of heat:
Acid + Base → Salt + Water + Heat
Situation 1: A red ant bit Keerthi, leaving her skin red with stinging pain. Her brother applied moist baking soda, which relieved the pain. What might be the reason? What remedies do people use for ant bites in your region?
- When an ant bites, it injects an acidic liquid — formic acid — into the skin, which causes the burning pain.
- Baking soda is a base. Rubbing moist baking soda on the spot neutralises the acid, so the pain is relieved.
Other common remedies: applying calamine lotion (which contains zinc carbonate, a base), lime (chuna), or a paste of baking soda and water.
Situation 2: A farmer’s plants are not growing well; excessive use of chemical fertilisers has made the soil acidic. What remedy might be provided? And what if the soil is basic?
| Nature of soil | Treatment | Why it works |
|---|---|---|
| Too acidic | Add lime (chuna) / quick lime / slaked lime | Lime is a base; it neutralises the excess acid. |
| Too basic | Add organic matter — manure, composted leaves | Organic matter releases acids that neutralise the basic nature. |
| Neutral but plants still unhealthy | Add the missing nutrients | Poor health may be due to a deficiency of nutrients in the soil, not its acidity. |
Situation 3: The fish population in a lake near an industrial area is declining. What might be the cause? If the factory waste is acidic, what could be done to save the fish?
- Probable cause: factory waste being released into the lake, which makes the lake water acidic and harmful for fish.
- Remedy: the factory waste should be neutralised by adding basic substances before it is released into the lake.
Let us wrap up! Why did the words ‘Welcome to the Wonderful World of Science’ appear on Ashwin and Keerthi’s white paper sheets when the liquid was sprayed on them?
A solution turns the red litmus paper to blue. Excess addition of which of the following solutions would reverse the change?
(i) Lime water (ii) Baking soda (iii) Vinegar (iv) Common salt solution
Answer: (iii) Vinegar
Explanation
- The given solution turns red litmus blue → it is basic.
- To reverse the change (make the litmus red again), we must make the solution acidic. That needs an acid in excess.
- Vinegar (acetic acid) is the only acid in the list.
Solution A turns red litmus blue; turmeric turns red in solution B; red rose extract turns green in solution C. Which is the correct sequence for A, B and C?
(i) Acidic, acidic, acidic (ii) Neutral, basic, basic (iii) Basic, basic, acidic (iv) Basic, basic, basic
Answer: (iv) Basic, basic, and basic
| Solution | Indicator & observation | Rule | Nature |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | Red litmus → blue | Bases turn red litmus blue | Basic |
| B | Turmeric → red | Turmeric turns red only in bases | Basic |
| C | Red rose extract → green | Rose extract is green in bases (red in acids) | Basic |
Observe and analyse Figs. 2.13, 2.14 and 2.15, in which red rose extract paper strips are used. Label the nature of the solutions present in each container.
| Figure | Colour of the rose-extract strip | Nature of the solution |
|---|---|---|
| Fig. 2.13 | Turns green | Basic |
| Fig. 2.14 | No change in colour | Neutral |
| Fig. 2.15 | Turns red | Acidic |
A liquid was tested: red litmus – no change; blue litmus – turned red; turmeric – no change in colour. Identify the nature of the liquid and justify.
The liquid is ACIDIC in nature.
| Indicator | Observation | What it proves |
|---|---|---|
| Blue litmus | Turned red | Only an acid turns blue litmus red → decisive proof |
| Red litmus | No change | It is not basic (a base would have turned it blue) |
| Turmeric | No change (stays yellow) | Again not basic; turmeric cannot separate acidic from neutral |
Manya is blindfolded. She is given two unknown solutions and must decide whether they are acidic or basic. Which indicator should she use and why?
She should use an olfactory indicator — for example onion strips (or vanilla extract, or clove oil).
Why
- Being blindfolded, Manya cannot see any colour change, so litmus, turmeric and red rose extract are of no use to her.
- An olfactory indicator changes its odour in acidic and basic media — and odour can be smelled, not seen.
- How to use it: put a few drops of each solution on separate onion-treated strips.
- Strip on which the onion smell disappears → the solution is basic.
- Strip on which the onion smell remains → the solution is acidic.
Suggest various materials which can be used for writing the message on the white sheet and what could be in the spray bottle. Make a table of possible combinations and the colour of the writing obtained.
The trick needs two things: an invisible writing liquid (an acid or a base) and a spray of an indicator that changes colour with it.
| # | Written on the paper with | Sprayed from the bottle | Colour of the writing that appears |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Soap solution (base) | Turmeric solution | Red writing on yellow paper |
| 2 | Baking soda solution (base) | Turmeric solution | Red writing |
| 3 | Lime water / Washing powder solution (base) | Turmeric solution | Red writing |
| 4 | Baking soda solution (base) | Red rose extract | Green writing |
| 5 | Lemon juice / Vinegar (acid) | Red rose extract | Red writing |
| 6 | Soap solution (base) | Red litmus solution | Blue writing |
| 7 | Lemon juice (acid) | Blue litmus solution | Red writing |
Grape juice was mixed with red rose extract; the mixture got a tint of red. What will happen if baking soda is added to this mixture? Justify.
Keerthi wrote a secret message using orange juice. Which indicator would you use to make it visible?
Another good choice: spray red rose extract (or China rose / purple cabbage extract) → the message appears in a shade of red.
How can natural indicators be prepared? Explain by giving an example.
Natural indicators are prepared as an extract of a coloured flower, vegetable or spice.
Example — Red rose extract (Activity 2.3)
Another example — Turmeric paper (Activity 2.5)
Make a paste of turmeric with a little water, dip filter paper in it, dry it, and cut it into strips. It turns red in basic solutions.
Other natural indicators: purple cabbage, beetroot, jamun, red hibiscus (gudhal), lichen (litmus).
Three liquids: vinegar, baking soda solution, sugar solution. Can you identify them only using turmeric paper? Explain.
No — not completely. Turmeric paper can identify only one of the three.
| Liquid | Nature | Effect on turmeric paper | Can it be identified? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baking soda solution | Basic | Turns red | ✔ Yes |
| Vinegar | Acidic | No change (yellow) | ✘ No |
| Sugar solution | Neutral | No change (yellow) | ✘ No |
Explanation
Turmeric cannot differentiate between an acidic and a neutral substance — both leave it yellow. So vinegar and sugar solution give identical results.
The extract of red rose turns liquid X to green. What will the nature of X be? What will happen when excess of amla juice is added to X?
Complete the missing information in the flowchart about a garden with plants showing signs of poor health.
| Blank | Correct answer |
|---|---|
| The soil can be ____ in nature. (left) | Acidic |
| The soil can be ____ in nature. (right) | Basic |
| Which indicator can be used to test the soil? | Litmus paper (red and blue) — turmeric paper or red rose extract can also be used |
| The acidic soil can be treated with ____ | Lime (chuna) — a base |
| The basic soil can be treated with ____ | Organic matter — manure / composted leaves |
Dive Deeper: Aman spilt vinegar on pieces of eggshell/marble and noticed bubbling. With a soap solution on another piece, no bubbles appeared. Why?
Carbonate + Acid → Salt + Water + Carbon dioxide (gas)
Exploratory Projects — how to do them.
- Rangoli with indicators: draw the design on paper/cloth with turmeric solution (yellow). Then, using a brush, paint parts of it with a soap or baking soda solution — those parts instantly turn red. Use red rose or beetroot extract for pink/green shades to get more colours.
- Water from various sources: test rain water, tap water and river water with red and blue litmus. Tap water is usually neutral; rain water can be slightly acidic; river water near industry may be acidic or basic. Record and compare in a table.
- Soil of your area: shake a soil sample with distilled water, let it settle, and test the clear liquid with red and blue litmus. Blue → red means acidic soil (treat with lime); red → blue means basic soil (add manure/compost); no change means neutral.
Extra numerical practice: In Activity 2.7 a student takes 1 drop of lemon juice and adds 20 drops of water. If 1 drop = 0.05 mL, find (a) the total volume of the solution, and (b) the fraction of lemon juice in it.
